Synthetic food colours in sweets: what does the science say about children and adults?
Brightly coloured sweets catch the eye. What does research say about synthetic food colours, especially in young children? Some evidence suggests that certain colours can affect activity and attention in some children. Responses vary, and the studies do not establish that these colours cause ADHD.
What are synthetic food colours?
Synthetic colours are manufactured to add colour to food. On EU labels, an approved colour is listed by name or E number. Some E numbers refer to colours of natural origin, and each substance is assessed on its own merits.
What did the Southampton study find?
The 2007 study included children aged three and eight to nine. Certain mixtures of artificial colours and sodium benzoate were associated with changes in hyperactive behaviour. Because the researchers tested mixtures, the results cannot isolate the effect of any one colour or establish that food colours cause ADHD. See the Southampton study in The Lancet.
What does more recent research say?
A 2021 assessment by California’s Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) found evidence that synthetic food dyes can contribute to hyperactivity and other changes in behaviour in some children. A 2022 publication from the same research programme reviewed human and animal studies. Findings vary across studies, and children differ in their sensitivity. See the OEHHA assessment and the review by Miller and colleagues.
Why do some sweets carry a warning?
EU law requires a warning about possible adverse effects on children’s activity and attention for six colours, subject to exemptions: E102 (tartrazine), E104 (quinoline yellow), E110 (sunset yellow FCF), E122 (carmoisine), E124 (ponceau 4R) and E129 (allura red AC). The wording describes a possible effect. See Annex V of Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008.
What do EFSA and the FDA say?
EFSA judged the Southampton study to provide limited evidence of a small effect from the mixtures tested in some children. The findings could not be attributed to individual colours. The US FDA also discusses the possibility that some children are sensitive to food colours. Methods and mixtures differ between studies. See EFSA’s assessment and the FDA’s information on colour additives.
What about adults?
Most research on activity and attention has focused on children. Evidence of comparable behavioural effects in adults is limited. Some people report hypersensitivity reactions to particular colours, a separate issue from hyperactivity. Controlled tests do not always confirm suspected reactions. A clinician can assess symptoms if you suspect a reaction.
How can you spot colours on a label?
Check the ingredients for colour names or E numbers and look for the warning where required. The origin of a colour alone tells you little about its safety or suitability.
Making an informed choice at CandyMixMatch
Compare the ingredients in sugar-free liquorice cats and Harlekijntjes soft sweet liquorice. The current product information lists both as free from synthetic colours. Check the latest ingredients on the product page and packaging.
For more, read our guide to reading a sweet label and our article on mindful snacking with sugar-free sweets.
In brief
Evidence suggests that some children are sensitive to certain synthetic food colours. The EU warning applies to six colours. The ingredients list and any warning are the best places to start when comparing sweets.
Sources
- McCann et al. (2007), The Lancet – Southampton study
- OEHHA (2021) – assessment of synthetic food dyes and children's behaviour
- Miller et al. (2022) – review of human and animal evidence
- EU – Regulation (EC) No 1333/2008, Annex V
- EFSA (2008) – evaluation of the Southampton study
- FDA – information on colour additives
This article provides general information about food and is not medical advice.
